';

Reasonable excuse: appealing an HMRC late filing penalty

HMRC penalties

Reasonable excuse: appealing an HMRC late filing penalty

If you missed a tax deadline because of something outside your control, you may be able to cancel the penalty by showing a reasonable excuse.

AABy Asim AbbasUpdated 12 November 20263 min read
Person appealing an HMRC penalty
In 30 seconds
  • Appeal within 30 days of the penalty notice
  • The excuse must cover the whole delay
  • You must fix the problem without delay after
  • Lack of money or relying on someone rarely works

HMRC accepts some reasons and rejects others, and the timing of your appeal matters.

This guide explains what counts, how to appeal and what to include.

Excuses HMRC may accept

  • Death of a partner or close relative shortly before the deadline
  • Unexpected hospital stay or serious illness
  • Serious IT failure while preparing your return
  • HMRC online service problems
  • Fire, flood or theft preventing you filing
  • Postal delays you couldn’t have predicted
  • Disability or mental health issues affecting your ability to file

Excuses usually rejected

  • Relying on someone else who let you down, unless you took reasonable care
  • Finding the online system difficult
  • Not receiving a reminder
  • Not being able to pay
  • Making a mistake on the return

Late tax return penalty calculator

Penalties you face.

Check
For example

Paul was admitted to hospital on 20 January 2026 and discharged on 10 February. He filed his 2024/25 return on 14 February and appealed the £100 penalty with his discharge letter. HMRC accepted the reasonable excuse because he filed promptly once well.

How to appeal

Appeal online through your HMRC account or using form SA370 for Self Assessment penalties. Explain what happened, when, and how it stopped you filing. Include evidence such as medical letters.

Fixed-fee accountancy support

Transparent monthly packages for sole traders, landlords and limited companies. Fixed fees agreed upfront, VAT included.

Get a fixed-fee quoteCall 0161 531 4179

If HMRC rejects your appeal

You can ask for an independent review within HMRC, or appeal to the First-tier Tribunal within 30 days. Many penalty appeals are decided on paper.

Late appeals

If you missed the 30-day deadline, you can still appeal if you had a good reason for the delay.

Interest

Even if a penalty is cancelled, interest on late tax normally still applies.

See HMRC’s guidance on reasonable excuses, our late penalties guide and our late tax returns service.

What should I do next?

File the return first

As soon as possible.

Gather evidence

Medical letters, dates.

Appeal within 30 days

Online or SA370.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a reasonable excuse?

Something outside your control that stopped you meeting the deadline.

How long do I have to appeal?

30 days from the penalty notice.

Is not having money a reasonable excuse?

Usually not.

Can I appeal online?

Yes, or using form SA370.

What if HMRC rejects my appeal?

Ask for a review or appeal to the tribunal.

Need help with this? Wingate Accountants offers fixed-fee online accountancy support across the UK. Call 0161 531 4179 or request a quote at wingateaccountants.co.uk.

AA

About the Author

Asim Abbas
I’m Asim Abbas, founder of Wingate Accountants and a Chartered Certified Accountant. I help sole traders, landlords and directors stay on top of their tax with fixed fees and plain-English advice.

Found this useful? Share it

★★★★★ Client reviewsWhat our clients say

Software we work with

Our partners

We work with the UK’s leading accounting and tax software, so you can keep the tools you know, or we can help you choose and move to the right one.

  • FreeAgent logo
  • Xero logo
  • Pandle logo
  • QuickBooks logo
  • Sage logo
  • TaxCalc logo
  • CloudConnect logo
  • Zoho logo
Making Tax Digital readyCloud bookkeeping set up for youHelp switching software

Wingate Accountants Ltd is an independent firm of Chartered Certified Accountants, providing tax and compliance services to individuals and businesses across the UK.

✔ HMRC Registered Tax Agent
✔ Companies House ACSP (Authorised Corporate Service Provider)
✔ Data Protection registration No. ZB868558
✔ Fully AML compliant

Find us on: Trustpilot · Yell · Thomson Local · Cylex · ProvenExpert · Facebook · Companies House

Contact Us

Hours

Monday to Friday : 09:00 – 17:00 Saturday & Sunday : Closed

Copyright © 2026 Wingate Accountants Ltd · Chartered Certified Accountants · Registered in England & Wales No. 15494836 · All rights reserved.