Made a mistake on your tax return? Errors, penalties and how to fix them
Made a mistake on your tax return? Errors, penalties and how to fix them
Mistakes on tax returns are common. What matters is how you put them right, and how HMRC judges the reason for the error.

- You can amend a return within 12 months of the deadline.
- Genuine mistakes despite reasonable care aren’t penalised.
- Careless errors can cost up to 30% of the extra tax.
- Telling HMRC first reduces penalties.
In this guide, we cover fixing a recent return, errors in older years, how hmrc sets penalties and getting help.
Fixing a recent return
If you spot a mistake, you can amend your Self Assessment return online or through your accountant within 12 months of the 31 January filing deadline. For the 2025/26 return, that means by 31 January 2028. HMRC recalculates the tax and you pay any extra, plus interest. Our guide to amending a tax return explains the steps.
Errors in older years
Once the amendment window has closed, you’ll need to write to HMRC or make a voluntary disclosure. HMRC can usually go back 4 years for genuine mistakes, 6 years for careless errors and up to 20 years for deliberate ones.
Estimate tax, interest and penalties
For a voluntary disclosure.
How HMRC sets penalties
Penalties depend on why the error happened and are a percentage of the extra tax due:
- Reasonable care taken: no penalty.
- Careless: up to 30%.
- Deliberate: 20% to 70%.
- Deliberate and concealed: 30% to 100%.
Penalties are reduced if you tell HMRC before it finds the error (an unprompted disclosure) and help it to put things right. A careless, unprompted disclosure can bring the penalty down to nil.
Fixed-fee accountancy support
Transparent monthly packages for sole traders, landlords and limited companies. Fixed fees agreed upfront, VAT included.
Get a fixed-fee quoteCall 0161 531 4179Getting help
If the mistake involves several years or significant sums, take advice before you contact HMRC. Our voluntary disclosure service and disclosure calculator can help you understand what you may owe.
What should I do next?
Which year and how much?
Depending on timing.
To keep penalties low.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will HMRC fine me for an honest mistake?
Not if you took reasonable care, for example by keeping proper records and checking your figures. Interest is still charged on any tax paid late.
Can I get a refund if I overpaid?
Yes. Amending a return to show less tax due creates a repayment. Older overpayments can be claimed through overpayment relief within four years.
What counts as careless?
Failing to take reasonable care, such as not keeping records or guessing figures without checking them.
Does an accountant protect me from penalties?
Using a competent adviser and giving them full information is good evidence of reasonable care, but you remain responsible for your return.
Need help with this? Wingate Accountants offers fixed-fee online accountancy support across the UK. Call 0161 531 4179 or request a quote at wingateaccountants.co.uk.
About the Author
Asim Abbas
I’m Asim Abbas, founder of Wingate Accountants and a Chartered Certified Accountant. I help sole traders, landlords and directors stay on top of their tax with fixed fees and plain-English advice.








