Should you use an accountant or file your own tax return?
Should you use an accountant or file your own tax return?
HMRC lets you file your own return free of charge, so is an accountant worth it? It depends on how complicated your affairs are and how much your time is worth.

- Filing yourself is free but you carry the risk.
- An accountant can find reliefs and expenses you’d miss.
- Complex income or HMRC letters favour professional help.
- Our fixed fees start at £150 including VAT.
In this guide, we cover filing your own return, what an accountant adds, when professional help makes most sense and what it costs.
Filing your own return
HMRC’s own service is free to use, and for someone with one simple income source it can work well. You answer questions, HMRC calculates the tax and you pay by 31 January.
The drawback is that HMRC’s system only records what you tell it. It won’t suggest expenses you’ve forgotten, point out a relief you qualify for, or warn you when an answer looks wrong. If you make a mistake, you’re responsible for any penalty.
What an accountant adds
- Accuracy: figures are checked and reconciled before anything is filed.
- Savings: allowable expenses, capital allowances and reliefs are claimed properly.
- Time: you hand over your records instead of learning the rules each year.
- Representation: once authorised as your agent, we deal with HMRC letters and enquiries for you.
- Planning: we flag payments on account, Making Tax Digital and year-end opportunities in advance.
See your likely tax bill
Get an estimate before deciding.
When professional help makes most sense
Doing it yourself is reasonable if you have one job and a small amount of savings interest. It’s worth talking to an accountant if any of these apply:
- You’re self-employed or have rental income.
- You’ve sold property, shares or crypto.
- Your income is close to £60,000, £100,000 or £125,140.
- You have foreign income or you’ve moved to or from the UK.
- You’ve received a letter from HMRC, or you’re behind with returns.
Fixed-fee accountancy support
Transparent monthly packages for sole traders, landlords and limited companies. Fixed fees agreed upfront, VAT included.
Get a fixed-fee quoteCall 0161 531 4179What it costs
Our fixed fees are £150 for a straightforward Self Assessment return and £250 for returns with more income sources, such as rental property. Complex cases are quoted individually, and all prices include VAT. Read more in how much an accountant charges for a tax return.
For many clients, the expenses and reliefs we identify more than cover the fee, and the peace of mind is hard to put a price on.
What should I do next?
How many sources do you have?
And the risk of mistakes.
Fixed fee, agreed upfront.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it legal to file my own tax return?
Yes. Anyone can file their own return through HMRC. You don’t need an accountant, but you’re responsible for getting it right.
Will using an accountant reduce my tax?
Often, yes. Accountants make sure you claim every allowable expense and relief you’re entitled to, within the rules.
Can an accountant deal with HMRC for me?
Yes. Once you authorise us as your agent, HMRC will talk to us about your tax affairs.
Can I switch to an accountant part way through the year?
Yes. We can take over at any point, including after HMRC has contacted you.
Need help with this? Wingate Accountants offers fixed-fee online accountancy support across the UK. Call 0161 531 4179 or request a quote at wingateaccountants.co.uk.
About the Author
Ali Imran
I’m Ali Imran, an accountant at Wingate Accountants. I help sole traders, landlords and directors get their returns filed early and accurately, without the last-minute panic.








