';

Car allowance or company car? Comparing the tax in 2026/27

Employee benefits

Car allowance or company car? Comparing the tax in 2026/27

Many employers offer a choice between a company car and a cash car allowance. The best option depends on the car you want, your tax rate and your business mileage.

SRBy Stephen ReynoldUpdated 11 November 20263 min read
Employee comparing car allowance and company car
In 30 seconds
  • Car allowance is taxed as salary
  • Electric company cars have a 4% BIK in 2026/27
  • Business mileage in your own car: up to 45p a mile tax-free
  • Consider salary sacrifice EV schemes

Electric company cars remain very tax-efficient, while a cash allowance is fully taxed as salary.

This guide compares the two, with worked examples for 2026/27.

Cash car allowance

A car allowance is extra salary, taxed through PAYE with Income Tax and NI. You then buy or lease a car yourself. Your employer can pay up to 45p a mile for business journeys tax-free, or you can claim relief on the difference if paid less.

Company car

A company car is taxed as a benefit in kind based on list price and CO2. Electric cars are taxed at 4% in 2026/27, rising to 5% in 2027/28, then 7% and 9%.

Salary after tax calculator

Car allowance take-home.

Calculate
For example

Sam, a higher rate taxpayer, is offered a £6,000 car allowance or an electric company car with a £40,000 list price. The allowance leaves £3,480 after 40% tax and 2% NI, to fund a car. The company car costs £640 a year in tax (4% × £40,000 × 40%), with the employer covering lease, insurance and servicing. For Sam, the EV is far better value.

Petrol and diesel company cars

With BIK rates of up to 37%, petrol and diesel company cars are expensive. A £35,000 petrol car at 30% costs a higher rate taxpayer £4,200 a year in tax, often making the allowance better.

Fixed-fee accountancy support

Transparent monthly packages for sole traders, landlords and limited companies. Fixed fees agreed upfront, VAT included.

Get a fixed-fee quoteCall 0161 531 4179

Business mileage

  • Own car: 45p a mile for the first 10,000, 25p after, tax-free
  • Company car: advisory fuel rates apply for reimbursement of business fuel, or the advisory electricity rate
  • Private fuel paid by employer: fuel benefit charge, not for electricity

Salary sacrifice EV schemes

Many employers offer EVs through salary sacrifice, giving tax and NI savings on the lease cost. See our salary sacrifice guide.

Other factors

  • Car allowance may count for pension and mortgage income
  • Company cars remove the risk of resale value
  • Payrolling benefits from April 2027 changes how BIK is collected

See HMRC’s guidance on company car tax, our BIK rates guide and our salary calculator.

What should I do next?

Get both offers in writing

Allowance and car.

Compare after-tax cost

Including running costs.

Check business mileage

45p rate.

Get advice

Talk to us.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a car allowance taxable?

Yes, as salary through PAYE.

Is an electric company car worth it?

Usually, with BIK at 4% in 2026/27.

Can I claim mileage with a car allowance?

Your employer can pay up to 45p a mile tax-free, or you can claim relief on any shortfall.

Is a petrol company car worth it?

Often not, with BIK up to 37%.

Does a car allowance count for pension?

It depends on your scheme rules.

Need help with this? Wingate Accountants offers fixed-fee online accountancy support across the UK. Call 0161 531 4179 or request a quote at wingateaccountants.co.uk.

SR

About the Author

Stephen Reynold
I’m Stephen Reynold, an accountant at Wingate Accountants. I work with sole traders and small companies, turning tax rules into clear, practical next steps.

Found this useful? Share it

★★★★★ Client reviewsWhat our clients say

Software we work with

Our partners

We work with the UK’s leading accounting and tax software, so you can keep the tools you know, or we can help you choose and move to the right one.

  • FreeAgent logo
  • Xero logo
  • Pandle logo
  • QuickBooks logo
  • Sage logo
  • TaxCalc logo
  • CloudConnect logo
  • Zoho logo
Making Tax Digital readyCloud bookkeeping set up for youHelp switching software

Wingate Accountants Ltd is an independent firm of Chartered Certified Accountants, providing tax and compliance services to individuals and businesses across the UK.

✔ HMRC Registered Tax Agent
✔ Companies House ACSP (Authorised Corporate Service Provider)
✔ Data Protection registration No. ZB868558
✔ Fully AML compliant

Find us on: Trustpilot · Yell · Thomson Local · Cylex · ProvenExpert · Facebook · Companies House

Contact Us

Hours

Monday to Friday : 09:00 – 17:00 Saturday & Sunday : Closed

Copyright © 2026 Wingate Accountants Ltd · Chartered Certified Accountants · Registered in England & Wales No. 15494836 · All rights reserved.